In trying to think up the title for this post, I kept thinking of the Muppets’ “Veterinarian Hospital: the continuing stooorrrrrrrry of a quack who’s gone to the dogs.” Haha. My continuing stoooorrrrrry of swimsuit sewing might also be about a quack who’s gone to the dogs. But you know what? Someday, I WILL create the perfect swimsuit that brings together the right fabric, the right fit, and the right style. It will be great. For now, I keep striving.
Today’s swimsuit is pretty good, but not quite there yet. This time around, I chose to try the Megan Nielsen Cottesloe Swimsuit paired with the Closet Core free Core T-shirt as a rash guard.
Like in 2021, when I made Butterick 4526 and Tilly & the Buttons’ Romy I wanted the convenience of a tankini with the look of clothes, so I could wear my swimsuit on adventures with my kids and be ready to swim (or not) at any time.
Because I was a pattern tester for the Megan Nielsen Protea Capsule Wardrobe pattern, I got to choose a free pattern, and I knew I wanted to try the Cottesloe. This pattern is, in many ways, nearly identical to Butterick 4526. It’s got a few slight differences, but I was hoping that this would have more appropriate ease. I was interested in all the views, but wanted to try the high waisted bikini with bands, View D, for my first attempt. My measurements were on the high end for the 0-20 size range and the low end for the 14-30 range. I went with the 14-30 pattern (16 bust, 18 waist and hips), but I’m not sure it was the right choice. Fortunately, the suit is functionally great.
It’s more that when I made it and tried it on, I was underwhelmed. The top didn’t look great. I think it would look better on a fuller bust, and I wonder if I would have been happier with the top in the 0-20 size range. The good news is, I am the only one who will see that, since I will always wear this with a rash guard, but regardless, I want to like all the elements of my outfit on me. You know?
I managed to just fit the pattern pieces onto leftovers of some of my favorite swimwear fabric (from this project), which I was happy about. The shoulder straps feel slightly wide and the back elastic tends to flip out, but I only notice that when I’m putting the suit on. Happily, the suit feels secure when I’m wearing it, and it has full coverage on the bottoms and the front of the top. I did swap in 3/8″ elastic where it called for 1/4″ on the neckline and armholes, since I find this to be much more secure. I also took my leg, waistband, and underbust elastic lengths from the Jalie 3023 tankini since Jalie has a proven activewear record and I like my suits to stay put.
I paired the suit with the Closet Core Core T-shirt pattern, which is a free pattern I have been wanting to try. I used View A, the cropped length with short sleeves and no pocket in a 16 bust and 18 waist and hip in the 0-20 size range.
I still have lots of striped swimwear fabric from 2020 from SpandexbyYard.com, and I really like it with the floral I used for the suit. I knew the top might be a little boxy, and it is. I could have made a straight 16 and it would have brought the sides in a bit. Length-wise, it’s not bad with the high rise bottoms of the suit. When dry, it’s a good match.
When swimming, it floats up quite a bit. I knew this would probably happen, and it doesn’t bug me too much most of the time. It’s definitely an improvement on the Tilly & the Buttons Romy I tried to use as a rash guard in 2021, which has been relegated to the thrift store.
I had a few nice details come together on the rash guard:
And here are some pictures of me wearing it. I don’t model my suits on the blog, but you can get an idea of the rash guard at least.
At this point, you may be coming to the same conclusion that I did. If I am sewing one or more suits a year, and still not getting just the right combination of elements, maybe I need to stop messing around and just use a swimwear pattern from a company that specializes in activewear and has a number of bathing suit patterns. The Cottesloe + Core T-shirt is a really nice suit, I like the fabric, and it stays put, but it’s just not there yet. For that reason, I have told myself that the next suit I sew has to be from Jalie. They specialize in activewear, skating costumes, swimwear, and they have everyday clothes. The patterns have also had a very expansive size range, from toddler to plus, in every or nearly every pattern as long as I have been aware of them. So, to that end, I have already cut out a tankini from Jalie 3023. Hopefully I can get it sewn up this month. The next time I need a rash guard, I should probably look to them, too.
I’ll get there eventually! 🙂